top of page

Private Credit's Headline Problems Belong to the Upper Market

Oct 29
2 min read

What's New

The stress in private credit headlines comes from the large end of the market, while lower and core middle-market lending still pays a premium. Tim Warrick, Managing Director and Head of Alternative Credit at Principal Asset Management, argues this in an interview on the InsuranceAUM.com Podcast. Warrick defines the lower middle market as companies with $5 to 15 million of EBITDA. Spreads there run at least a couple hundred basis points above broadly syndicated loans. Insurers should judge private credit by segment and stop treating it as one beta spread product.


Why It Matters

Upper middle-market and large-cap lenders compete directly with the syndicated loan market on leverage, covenant-light terms and price. Warrick says that segment is turning into beta. That challenges insurers who think they missed private credit after spreads compressed. It also challenges buyers of semi-liquid vehicles who pay for liquidity they do not need. Principal runs a lower and core middle-market platform and invests its own balance sheet in every loan, so the argument serves its book.


By The Numbers

  • 1.5 turns: how much lower leverage runs in the lower and core middle market than in the upper middle market.

  • 500 to 650 basis points: the spread range Principal sees today. Coupons average nearly 10%.

  • Over 80%: the share of Principal's covenants that tighten over the life of the loan.

  • About 3%: the share of deals Principal selects. It reviews about 1,000 a year.


Memorable Quotes

  • "I call it an inefficiency premium because the market's much less efficient." Warrick ties the excess return to a less efficient market with tighter covenants and lower leverage.

  • "This asset class kicks off regular liquidity given it only has a three-year average life." Short loans repay 20 to 35% a year, which gives insurers liquidity without a vehicle that charges for it.

  • "Some of the events are true credit concerns or issues that investors should be looking at and discerning." Warrick concedes that part of the bad news reflects real credit problems.

  • "You shouldn't want to pay for that liquidity if you're an insurance investor especially." The case for the lower middle market rests on insurers keeping the full illiquidity premium.


The Wrap

The segment premium lasts while lower and core middle-market loans keep maintenance covenants and a spread gap over syndicated loans. It erodes if secondary trading in the loans themselves grows and draws passive buyers down market. Warrick expects that trading to develop and warns it would make the segment more beta-like. The next 2 years, his own outlook window, will show whether the premium holds as new insurance and wealth capital arrives.

Comments


Subscribe to get exclusive updates

  • White Facebook Icon

© 2035 by TheHours. Powered and secured by Wix

bottom of page